What is it like to negotiate with Russian representatives regarding the conflict in Ukraine?
This question has piqued considerable interest following multiple recent sessions of peace discussions, which until now seemed to produce little progress half a decade after the comprehensive military offensive.
A further round of American-facilitated negotiations is likely to occur in Geneva later this week. Ahead of it, an important participant of the Ukrainian leadership's delegation, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has taken part in the latest military-to-military discussions, has shared his viewpoint.
As stated by Kyslytsya, these interactions are professional and generally devoid of the sort of ideological and rhetorical posturing seen elsewhere by Moscow.
"The military have a superior understanding of the realities in the combat zone," he remarked during a meeting earlier this week.
"It's another thing whether they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of relaying information directly…without cooking or distorting the facts," he added.
It is not an easy thing to attempt to end a war. The reality of the front line in the Donbas region - where thousands of drones operate and kill over a vast so-called "contested area" separating the opposing forces, while 200,000 Ukrainian civilians still live in the "fortress belt" cities of the Donbas - renders the technical business of separation extremely complicated.
"It is essential to have a clear framework of guidelines and protocols," Kyslytsya said, "and a method to verify and oversee."
The Role of External Mediators
Much of these preparations, he noted, is finished, thanks in part to the direct involvement of US representatives, including a senior NATO commander and a high-ranking Army official.
Clearly against Ukraine's benefit to criticise envoys of the current US administration, but when he praises the American team for its efforts, he comes across as genuine.
"We have to acknowledge the Americans for their commitment and their patience," he states, "since they sit in the meetings non-stop. They not only watch…they put questions and they listen to our answers."
Kyslytsya was equally complimentary about the roles played by the former president's adviser, whom he referred to as "not a novice", and billionaire envoy the special representative, whom he characterized as "far more astute individual than the simplified portrayal often presented in the press".
The United States, he asserted, will play a key role in overseeing any future ceasefire, with capabilities including satellite and other forms of high-tech surveillance.
"It is necessary to have someone who will serve as an arbitrator, for the reason that if there is a breach there should be a third party that is solid [and] respected."
Past and Present Oversight Challenges
During an eight-year period before the full-scale invasion in 2022, this oversight function was handled by the OSCE - a body whose limited means and absence of enforcement mechanisms rendered it largely incapable of averting an intensification.
"That was quite an achievement [for them] just to have two drones flying over the territory," Kyslytsya commented. "It's kind of the Flintstones period compared to what we have now."
By contrast, latest analyses suggest that as many as 12,000 unmanned aircraft are active above the urban center of Pokrovsk at any given moment.
An Insider's Perspective on Confronting the Adversary
Inquired about his ability to negotiate directly from emissaries representing a leader in the Kremlin who has shown readiness to sacrifice more than a million of his country's soldiers to conquer its neighbor, the diplomat, also a former UN ambassador, offered his answer.
He told that he'd had years of practice.
"I witnessed far more difficult situations. I spent a five-year term in New York, three of them before the major war. I regularly had to be present with the enemy on a regular basis."
One evening is etched in his memory: 23 February 2022.
During an urgent UN Security Council session, called to discuss the looming threat in Ukraine, the diplomat received news that his homeland was under attack.
At the same time, seven time zones to the east in the capital, the first distant detonations were heard as the all-out attack on the nation commenced.
Amid moments of agonising tension, Kyslytsya attempted to get his Russian counterpart, Vassily Nebenzia, to contact his superior, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to obtain guarantees that Russian forces would not cross the border.
"I've already said everything that I am aware of today," Nebenzia replied, according to his Ukrainian colleague. "I will not wake the minister at this hour."
The world changed at that moment. Kyslytsya remained at the United Nations for an additional period before going back to Kyiv.
The Road Ahead
If the negotiating teams meet again in Switzerland on Thursday, he'll be there, still working through the details and logistics of a ceasefire but anticipating continuously for the crucial part of the jigsaw to fall into place.
"Hostilities could be ended by simply a single order of an individual to his top general," he stated.
"However, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not prepared for ending the war for the time being."